We Were Born Old – On Chinese Contemporary Art


Maybe some of you have already heard or even visited the Ink Art: Past as Present in Contemporary China (http://www.metmuseum.org/exhibitions/listings/2013/ink-art) at the Metropolitan Museum in New York.  Recently, a symposium (Feb 23rd) on the same topic was held at the MET, which attracted a lot of attentions in Mainland China. Let’s just hold on for a moment on the reception of “Western” critics, but to see how numerous Chinese critics have been writing a gobs out of it.

I just read something written from a Mainland-China based beloved contemporary critic Pi Li(皮力), who holds a relatively negative assessment on it. On one hand, he thinks that a Chinese contemporary exhibition on the subject of ink is already not a smart decision, let alone it is taken place at the MET. The “nationalism group” would consider that as not traditional enough, but the avant-guard people won’t take that seriously as contemporary art either. So it seems to be placed in an embarrassed position in between. On the other hand, he also expressed his disappointment on the general reception of MET’s choice of “Ink” as a representation of the Chineseness, which means it is so welcomed in the West! (Chineseness lol)

Earlier in 2008, after the essay Mao Crazy (http://www.newrepublic.com/article/mao-crazy) written by Jed Perl published on New Republic, it caused a splash among the art scene in Mainland China. Interestingly, another essay titled Western Authorities Derided Chinese contemporary Art As Too Evil (which is a newly distorted translation of Mao Crazy) has been attracting a lot of attentions on the Internet recently. Critic Pi Li commented on that saying the so-called  “Western authorities” has become an imaginary enemy but at the same time a beautiful dream lover to the Chinese contemporary art world.

He claimed, if the mass art audiences in China are no longer immune to anything from the “Western Authorities”, the diffidence of Chinese contemporary art is again revealed underneath its hot and glamorous appearance. In the meanwhile, what are the “Western Authorities”? And why does it matter a ton thus become many people’s concerns.

Pi Li quoted this saying to describe his upsets: “We were born old, will never have a chance to grow up until we die.” Even though I totally understand his concern, but I am not as worried as he does. After all, IMHO, who cares about authorities and “Chineseness”, in the West?

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s